The Best Steak and Shrimp Recipes for Surf and Turf

The best steak and shrimp recipes are the special occasion recipes you want to serve on Valentine’s Day or any celebration meal. 

steak and shrimp dinner recipes

Sizzling Surf and Turf: a Culinary Adventure

Imagine this: You’re planning a special evening, perhaps it’s Valentine’s Day, or maybe just a date night that calls for something extraordinary. 

What could be more luxurious and indulgent than a sizzling plate of surf and turf? Not much, friends.

Combining the tender, juicy allure of a perfectly cooked steak with the delicate, savory flavors of fresh seafood, this meal is a symphony of taste that’s sure to impress. 

creamy tarragon shrimp

Whether it’s the rich, buttery taste of a filet mignon steak paired with succulent jumbo shrimp, or a robust New York strip steak accompanied by sweet sea scallops, surf and turf is the ultimate culinary adventure. 

It’s not only a feast for the taste buds but also a great way to show someone special just how much they mean to you. 

With each bite, the blend of land and sea offers a moment of pure bliss, marking the occasion as truly memorable. 

Key Takeaways:

  • Surf and turf combine steak and seafood for an opulent meal experience. 
  • Perfect for special occasions like Valentine’s Day or memorable date nights. 
  • Offers a luxurious culinary adventure, celebrating the best of both land and sea. 

Choosing the Right Ingredients

Embarking on a surf and turf journey begins with a crucial step: selecting the right ingredients

Imagine the aroma of sizzling sirloin steak paired with the delightful taste of succulent shrimp scampi, all made possible by choosing those perfect cuts and fresh catches. 

If you’ve never tried a Denver Steak, it’s a fantastic option for a special occasion that is well worth making.

Denver Steak

When strolling through the grocery store, reach for the best steak – think filet mignon steaks or New York strip steak, ensuring they boast a rich marbling and a bright, red hue. 

For the seafood, opt for plump jumbo shrimp or tender sea scallops, their fresh, briny scent is a promising sign of the feast to come. 

Remember, a good surf and turf is more than a meal; it’s a voyage of flavors, and it all starts with the ingredients you choose. 

Steak Selection and Preparation

When embarking on this culinary journey, the perfect ribeye steak stands out among the best steak selections for skillet garlic butter steak, not only for its rich flavor but also for its tenderness, making every bite a delight. 

perfect grilled ribeye steak

First, suppose you’re eyeing perfection. In that case, it’s crucial to let your steak acclimate to room temperature before it hits the hot skillet. 

This little bit of patience ensures your steak cooks evenly, achieving that coveted perfect sear without any cold centers. 

Now, seasoning – it’s where the magic happens! A simple yet effective combination of kosher salt, black pepper, and a touch of garlic powder works wonders. 

perfect steak marinade

However, for those adventurous souls, mix up Papa’s Steak Marinade, and have just the right kick, elevating the steak to new heights of flavor. The key is to coat evenly, ensuring every inch of your sirloin promises a burst of taste. I like to flip the steaks over and over in the marinade, so they have equal opportunity to soak up the flavor.

Trust me, with these steps, you’re well on your way to a skillet masterpiece that’ll have everyone asking for seconds. 

Seafood Pairings: Shrimp and Beyond

Once you’ve selected the perfect cut of steak, why not elevate your surf and turf to the next level with some exquisite seafood pairings? 

Quick Shrimp Cocktail Sauce Recipe

If you’re anything like me, shrimp is a go-to for its juicy tenderness and effortless charm alongside red meat. I tend to reach for jumbo shrimp, sautéed with a little olive oil, garlic powder, and lemon juice – it’s a simple yet supremely satisfying addition. 

My favorite way to enjoy shrimp is this Creamy Tarragon Shrimp! It’s a great appetizer, or spooned over your steak… scrumptious!

But let’s not stop there. 

Sea Scallops with Garlic Butter, with their sweet, succulent meat, can be seared in a hot skillet to achieve that perfect golden crust, offering a luxurious contrast to the savory steak. And for those really special occasions, lobster tails can be brushed with garlic butter, then broiled till lightly browned; a truly indulgent partner to your steak. 

Each of these seafood delights, from creamy garlic shrimp to buttery scallops and lobster tails, enriches your plate, creating a surf and turf dinner that’s both lavish and heartwarmingly delicious. 

Mastering the Skillet: Techniques for Perfection

Mastering the art of cooking both steak and seafood in a cast-iron skillet isn’t just about throwing them on heat; it’s an elegant dance of temperature control and timing. This post will walk you through the best temperature to grill steak, to get the best result.

grilling ribeye steak

I personally prefer the grill or a grill pan, but here are some tips for cooking an expensive cut of meat in a cast iron skillet.

First, ensure your steak is at room temperature and your skillet is screaming hot – this combination is the secret to achieving that perfect sear we all crave. 

The magic of a hot skillet cannot be overstated; it seals in juices, creating a tender steak with a nice crust, and renders juicy shrimp with just a few flips. 

When it comes to cooking time, less is often more. 

grilled tomahawk steak

I always keep a meat thermometer handy to ensure the level of doneness is just right, avoiding overcooked meat at all costs. I love having this instant-read thermometer right next to my stovetop. It makes it so easy to cook your favorite cut of steak of the perfect temperature.

Remember, good things come to those who wait – allow your steak to rest before cutting into it, ensuring every bite is as juicy and flavorful as possible. 

Garlic Butter and Sauces: Elevating Flavors

Let’s talk about turning your surf and turf into a culinary masterpiece with the secret weapon of every great chef: sauce! 

garlic shallot herb butter for steak

Specifically, let’s dive into the uncharted deliciousness of homemade garlic herb butter and how a creamy garlic shrimp sauce can elevate your steak and seafood from good to unforgettable. 

Imagine the sizzle of a hot skillet as you pan-sear your choice cut, the aromas mingling and promising a bite full of flavor. Now, envisage smothering your perfectly cooked steak and juicy shrimp in a buttery sauce rich with garlic, herbs, and a hint of lemon juice for that fresh zing. 

Imagine this: You’re in your kitchen preparing a special meal. You start with unsalted butter at room temperature, to which you add minced garlic cloves, a pinch of kosher salt, black pepper, and freshly chopped herbs like parsley or thyme. A small bowl suffices to combine these ingredients, creating a creamy concoction ready to melt enticingly over your sizzling steak and tender shrimp. 

The beauty of this homemade garlic herb butter lies in its simplicity and the profound impact it has on elevating the flavors in your dish. 


In this recipe for Steakhouse Chicken, you’ll find a recipe for a steak butter that is super amazing. This recipe is also fantastic if you’ve got someone coming who doesn’t eat red meat!

Add a creamy garlic shrimp sauce, with a base of chicken broth and a dash of white wine, and you’ve got yourself an irresistibly luxurious sauce that perfectly complements the red meat and brings out the best in your surf and turf experience. 

This isn’t just food; it’s a journey of flavors. 

If it’s a really super special occasion, start your meal with Tarragon Shrimp.

It is the best way to enjoy a great dinner. The creamy sauce of sherry, heavy cream, and butter coats every piece of shrimp, it’s so so good! I’ve never tried it, but I think it would make a great surf topping for a NY strip steak, ribeye, or filet.

Serving Suggestions and Side Dishes

Now, let’s talk about the perfect accompaniments to our surf and turf feast – those all-important side dishes that elevate the meal from great to unforgettable. 

crispy ranch brussels sprouts

Crispy Ranch Brussels Sprouts, roasted to caramelized perfection, make a delightful vegetable pairing, blending beautifully with the meat’s richness.

Imagine them lightly seasoned with olive oil and ranch powder, roasted so their crispy edges offer a satisfying crunch. 

For the starch lovers among us, there’s nothing quite like sweet potato casserole with pecan streusel topping. It’s the iconic famous Ruth’s Chris steakhouse that makes this pairing so alluring.

Tender asparagus, french green beans, or roasted broccoli are all fantastic side dishes to include as well. 

You can’t forget the wedge salads and mashed potatoes!

wedge salad with thousand island dressing

Starting your dinner menu with a Wedge Salad with Thousand Island Dressing is just top-notch.

Remember, the best part of meal planning is infusing your personal touch. Whether it’s a challenging day at work or a special date night, these side dishes promise to complement the main course beautifully, turning your dinner table into a culinary adventure worth remembering. 

Wine Pairing and The Final Touch

Choosing the perfect wine is like adding the final brushstroke to a masterpiece. 

For our sizzling surf and turf adventure, I lean towards a crisp Pinot Grigio or a light Chardonnay. These choices are not just drinks; they’re an integral part of the culinary experience, enhancing every subtle flavor of the steak and seafood on your plate. It’s amazing how a sip of Pinot Gris can bring out the sweetness of a juicy shrimp, or how a glass of Chardonnay can complement a tender steak. 

Trust me, the right wine doesn’t just accompany your meal; it elevates it, turning a simple dinner into an unforgettable dining experience. 

More Culinary Adventures Await

As we bring our sizzling journey of surf and turf to a delightful close, I can’t help but encourage you, the avid culinary explorer, to dive deeper into the vast sea of steak and seafood recipes that await. 

simple steak salad recipe

There’s something inherently thrilling about mastering the art and science behind cooking the perfect piece of succulent steak paired with the most delicately flavored seafood. Whether it’s the fiery kiss of a hot skillet on a good steak, the swirl of garlic herb butter melting over a tender piece of fillet mignon, or the dance of flavors in a skillet garlic butter steak and shrimp, the adventure never really ends. 

From honing the perfect sear to experimenting with a variety of sauces and sides, like creamy garlic shrimp or juicy shrimp scampi, your path to becoming a surf and turf maestro is paved with delicious challenges and unforgettable meals. 

So, don your apron, fire up the cast-iron skillet, and let the magic of creating mouthwatering steak and seafood dishes lead the way to more culinary adventures. After all, every bite is a step further into the heart of what makes cooking such a profound part of our lives. 

Similar Posts