Italian Cheese Spread

this post contains affiliate links.

Italian cheese spread is a simple appetizer idea, great for any cheese board. Leftover ingredients are layered together to create a delicious cheese spread!

Italian cheese spread

Town Mountain Supper Club started a few years ago with the dream of gathering people around the table for a good meal and good conversation.

We wanted to gather people we didn’t know so we could start relationships with them and create life around the table.

We all know each other very well, and we always have a fun time. What better way to get to know other people than at a super fun dinner party!

Most supper clubs are made up of the same people time after time — the traditional supper club. However, Town Mountain Supper Club had two reasons for asking different guests each month:

  1. We wanted to keep it interesting for us, the hosts.
  2. We wanted to show others that entertaining isn’t that difficult, and with a core group of people, you can do it too. 
italian cheese spread

Each month, one of the core members hosts supper club.

As the host, you choose the theme & menu, the guests, and anything else they think would be nice.

We’ve done all kinds of themes: 70s (fondue night!), Italian, French, Hawaiian, Spring Fresh, Mexican, Mardi Gras, Friendsgiving, BBQ, Burger Night, Low Country Boil (You can read how to host a low country boil!).

Choosing the theme is so much fun — but, we also like to choose themes based on what food items we want to have.

I knew I wanted to share my recipe of Beef Tenderloin with my special peeps, so we had a “fancy” dinner night.

We’re all major foodies, so we like to REALLY ball out on our once a month supper club! It gives us something to look forward to, and reminisce all at the same time!

italian cheese spread idea for appetizer

Recently, we opted for a sort of Italian themed night — more of Carrabas Restaurant theme!

We all chose recipes that were either on the menu currently, or once upon a time.

I had the appetizer, and being the enneagram type 3 that I am (3’s are the Achievers!), I chose to do a whole Grazing Board filled with Bruschetta toppings of all kinds.

I’ve shared this Tomato Salad for topping Garlic Herb Bruschetta. It really is out of this world — I’ve been scheming on how I can justify making this every day…

The entire board is a bit of work, but when you make it ahead of time, it’s not that bad. 

italian cheese spread made with trader joe's sun dried cherry tomatoes, goat cheese, and fresh basil.

Italian Cheese Spread takes the leftover parts from all the other bruschetta grazing board “pieces” and creates an entirely new appetizer idea. Fresh basil and goat cheese are layered with sun-dried cherry tomatoes. In Trader Joe’s, these are called “Antipasto Cherry Tomatoes.” They are ready for an antipasto platter — piled high with olives and cheese! I’ve even layered them on a skewer as “Caprese salad bites.” 

Tools you’ll need for this recipe:

  • Clear jar or bowl (you’ll want to see the layers! They look like the Italian flag!)
  • Spreading knife
  • Fork
Bruschetta Bar topping ideas

Ingredients you’ll need for this recipe:

  • Antipasto Tomatoes (If you don’t have a Trader Joe’s close by, or TJ’s is all out, sun-dried tomatoes would be SO good in this!)
  • Goat Cheese
  • Fresh Basil Leaves

All of these items were leftover from the big grazing board. When I realized I had enough to create a cheese spread appetizer, instead of putting all these ingredients back in the fridge, I just layered them into a jar, screwed the lid on, and added it to the board.

Other ways to use this Italian Cheese Spread:

  • This would make a fantastic hostess gift idea! You could make this up to several days in advance, and then bring along with a bag of homemade Garlic Herb Toasties.
  • This Italian Cheese Spread takes the ordinary grilled chicken to extraordinary when you spread on top after you’ve pulled your chicken from the grill! 
italian cheese spread

One of the reasons I wrote the Hostess Handbook is to share how easy it is to entertain. When you take away all of social media’s expectations, you are left with a humble dinner around the table.

Simple recipes and easy decor tips are exactly what I share inside this 90+ page workbook.

It’s filled with recipes that are easy to pronounce, easy to fix, and most of them can be made ahead of time. You’ll learn to create a buffet table that IS insta-worthy, and how you can pick up all the items at the market.

clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
italian cheese spread

Italian Cheese Spread

  • Author: Sweetpea
  • Prep Time: 8
  • Total Time: 8 minutes
  • Category: appetizer
  • Method: cheese spread
  • Cuisine: italian


Italian Cheese Spread is a simple appetizer idea, great for any cheese board.


  • 4 ounces Goat Cheese, softened
  • 4 ounces Antipasto Tomatoes (or Sun Dried Tomatoes)
  • 2 tbs Torn Fresh Basil Leaves


  1. In a glass jar or bowl, layer the goat cheese, tomatoes, and basil over and over until you’re to the top.
  2. Serve with Garlic Herb Toasties.


This keeps well in an airtight container for up to a week.

Recipe Card powered byTasty Recipes
italian cheese spread appetizer recipe idea

What recipes do you make that you love sharing with people over and over?!

Similar Posts


  1. This looks fabulous! What a great recipe to sit around, reminiscing with friends while enjoying this savory snack!

  2. I really like simple recipes that allow to enjoy a good company with great food more often because you don’t need to stay in the kitchen for too long. This is a good idea for cheeseboards, too.

    1. You and me both!!! I think this is why so many people don’t entertain more often. Thanks for stopping by!

  3. Oh my gosh, your supper club sounds like such fun and this cheese spread sounds amazing. I can think of so many things that I would use it on!

    1. Oh, it is fun!! 😉 Hope you can try the cheese spread soon! Thanks for stopping by!

Comments are closed.